The June 2026 edition of The Nation magazine included an article by Alex Shams. Shams' article was titled as follows: "Why Did So Many People Think This War Was A Good Idea?" The war referred to, initiated by our current president, is the War in Iran.
Shams' article is well worth reading, and focuses on support for the war inside Iran, and support from those Iranians living outside Iran. The article begins with a short summary of what the reader is going to be told. Here is what Shams says by way of his introduction to the article: "The story of how millions of Iranians fell for the regime-change fantasy."
To let you in on at least one explanation advanced by Shams, many Iranians, both inside and outside Iran, apparently put a lot of faith in the guy who started the war, thinking that he truly was, as he has always claimed to be, really smart, and that he could certainly pull it all off. Hearing this, you probably don't immediately think of the following line from Bob Dylan, but I do (click the link for the lyrics to "Bob Dylan's 115th Dream"):
I will let anyone who becomes interested in the question addressed in this blog posting read the Shams' article themselves (I hope it will be available to non-subscribers). Here's the thought that I want to advance, both with specific reference to the War in Iran and with respect to war more generally (emphasis added):
There was little discussion of how exactly military strikes would lead to the collapse of Iran’s government. But the possibility raised unrealistic expectations inside Iran. To millions of people still reeling from January’s mass killings, it offered a fantasy that the US could swoop in, remove the government, and replace it with something else—without touching the Iranian people.
Almost overnight, Iranians who spoke out against war were accused of being “apologists” for the government.
“War will kill fewer people than the regime, so it will save lives in the long term. It’s simple math” was another.
“What’s your alternative?” was yet a third.
A quieter chorus warned against the lure of war. “We stand for peace,” Masoud Nikzadi, a historian in Tehran, wrote on Instagram. “We don’t need to explain a plan for why peace is necessary. Those who support war must explain how exactly it will bring freedom.”
A collective of women from the Baloch minority, formed during the 2022 Woman Life Freedom protests, warned: “War should not be sold as an opportunity to people under oppression. Militarization…leads to social collapse and disintegration, just as happened in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, and Syria.”
But these voices in Iran, lacking large social-media platforms, were drowned out by influencers and celebrities abroad, whose message was embraced by those within the country.
George Orwell got it right a long time ago. "War" is NOT "Peace." And we don't achieve "peace" by pursuing "war."
Wouldn't it be great if we had a president who understood this fact?
https://www.thenation.com/article/world/iran-regime-change-fantasy/
















